StrawberryNet.com, my reviews are always honest however, and not influenced by anything other than how I personally feel about them.
This mascara comes in a luxurious (how many times can I say luxurious?) heavy, slender gold tube. I have this in colour 02 Rich Brown. I know most people opt for black mascara, but I find they can look too stark on me and I prefer a dark brown, this dark brown is quite dark too. I got this from StrawberryNet.com for $19 CAD (the black is more expensive), much cheaper than I would of spent in the store, which would of been like $31.50 CAD I believe. And StrawberryNet is offering an additional 10% off everything at the moment too.
The other issue with it is you get 7.5ml with the YSL and 13.1ml with the Cover Girl, so while the tube looks hefty, the amount that you get is much less. Mascaras typically only last 6 month before you should throw it away, and I have read that the YSL gets dry after 3 months. Personally, I keep mascaras past the 6 month mark because I use so many at once, so to me, it's not an issue, but something to consider.
Would I recommend this product? If you only buy a couple mascaras a year, yes I would recommend this one since it's pretty great. If you like switching up your mascaras and already own many drugstores ones, I would say stick to them.